Buy-Sell insurance: Are you exposed?
A business valued at $10 million, four owners, and a combined premium of approximately $1000 per month.
For many business owners, the cost of a Buy-Sell insurance policy is not the challenge. Understanding what happens without one is.
While Buy-Sell insurance is often mistaken with Key Person insurance, the two solve very different problems. Key Person insurance protects the business itself, while Buy-Sell insurance helps fund the transfer of ownership if a shareholder dies or becomes permanently disabled.
This is critical because it helps ensure the surviving spouse or estate receives the value of the deceased / permanently disabled shareholder’s ownership interest, while enabling the remaining owners to retain control of the business.
To illustrate how it works, let’s look at a common business ownership scenario.
Meet the business owners
Nick, Tom, Mary and Paul have built a successful business together.
- Nick owns 55% of the business
- Tom owns 15%
- Mary owns 15%
- Paul owns 15%
The business is valued at approximately $10 million. Without Buy-Sell insurance, the remaining shareholders could be left needing to source significant capital to purchase a departing owner’s interest following death or permanent disability.
In this example, that $10 million ownership exposure could potentially be protected for around $1,000 per month.
*Paul’s premium is higher due to his smoking status.
*TPD stands for Total and Permanent Disablement.
As the owners begin discussing Buy-Sell insurance, a number of important questions emerge.
“Who pays for it all?”
This is usually one of the first questions raised. In our experience, it is most common for the business to pay for the insurance, with the premium treated as a non-tax-deductible business expense.
For Nick, Tom, Mary and Paul, the initial focus is naturally on the cost. However, the discussion quickly shifts from the premium to the potential financial exposure if no funding mechanism exists.
In their case, they can potentially be protected for $1,000 per month. Without Buy-Sell insurance, the remaining shareholders may be required to:
- Find significant capital at short notice
- Borrow funds to complete a buyout
- Negotiate alternative arrangements with beneficiaries
- Accept unintended ownership changes within the business
The premium is often the most visible cost, but it is usually the potential funding gap that carries the greater risk.
“Paul is a smoker. Why does that affect the premium?”
One of the more interesting discussions in this example centres around Paul. Although he owns the same 15% shareholding as Mary and Tom, his premium is almost double theirs.
Insurance premiums are assessed individually. Factors such as age, occupation, medical history, health and lifestyle choices can influence the cost of cover.
In Paul’s case, his smoking status results in a higher premium despite holding exactly the same ownership percentage as the other minority shareholders.
Importantly, this does not change the purpose of Buy-Sell insurance. The goal remains the same: ensuring there is sufficient funding available to facilitate an ownership transfer when required and provide the shareholder’s estate with the agreed value of their share.
“What if they own more of the business than I do?”
Not all shareholders have equal ownership interests and a Buy-Sell insurance policy should reflect that reality.
In this example, Nick owns 55% of the business, representing approximately $5,500,000 of the total business value. Tom, Mary and Paul each own 15%, representing approximately $1,500,000 each.
As a result, Nick requires a larger sum insured because there is a larger ownership interest that may ultimately need to be transferred. This highlights an important principle of Buy-Sell planning: the insurance should reflect the value of every shareholder’s equity rather than applying the same amount of cover to every owner.
A well-structured plan aligns ownership percentages, business value and insurance funding so they work together when the policy is called upon.
“What if the sum insured isn’t high enough?”
This is one of the most overlooked risks in Buy-Sell planning. The value of a business rarely stays the same. As businesses grow, revenues increase, new clients are acquired and assets appreciate in value. A valuation that was appropriate five years ago may be significantly different today.
If Nick, Tom, Mary and Paul never review their policy, there is a risk the insurance funding may no longer be sufficient to support a future ownership transfer.
If the sum insured falls short of the value required to buy out an exiting shareholder, the remaining shareholders will need to fund the difference. This could mean taking out a bank loan or drawing on their own personal financial resources.
Where sufficient capital is not available, the implications can be more significant. The business may need to introduce a new third-party shareholder, consider a sale of the business, or have the exiting shareholder’s estate remain as an equity holder.
Regular reviews can help reduce this risk by ensuring:
- Business valuations remain current
- Shareholding percentages are accurately reflected
- Insurance cover remains adequate
- New business partners are incorporated where necessary
Like any business protection strategy, a Buy-Sell insurance policy should evolve alongside the business itself.
“What if one of us have a pre-existing medical condition?”
Pre-existing medical conditions can affect the cost and availability of cover. Depending on the condition, insurers may apply:
- Premium loadings
- Policy exclusions
- Alternative underwriting terms
- Some or all covers may not be available at all.
This is why succession planning is often easier to address early, before health issues arise. Waiting can reduce options and increase costs.
For business owners like Nick, Tom, Mary and Paul, establishing a Buy-Sell arrangement while all parties remain insurable often provides greater flexibility and certainty.
Looking beyond the premium
For these four business owners, the conversation ultimately comes back to one question:
“What would happen if one of us could no longer participate in the business tomorrow?”
In their case, approximately $10 million of ownership exposure could potentially be protected for around $1,000 per month.
While Paul’s premium is higher due to his smoking status, the broader purpose of the plan remains unchanged. The policy helps ensure ownership can be transferred smoothly, provides certainty to the remaining shareholders and helps the departing owner’s family or estate receive fair value for their interest in the business.
When viewed in that context, the premium often becomes a much smaller part of the discussion. The more important consideration is whether the business has a clear and funded plan in place for when the unexpected occurs.
In our next instalment, we’ll examine a real-life Buy-Sell scenario where an unexpected event occurred, and the importance of having the right ownership and funding arrangements already in place.
To find out more, or to review your buy-sell insurance, talk to our insurance expert, Miguel Frances at mfrances@pno.com.au or call (03) 9536 7357.
